A Percy Jackson x Annabeth Chase story. Sequel to A God in Disguise, Pontus finds he cannot truly stop the inevitable monster-demigod cycle. That sucks for him, because the monsters are planning their release. There are two options open to him: somehow make poo jewelry to (hopefully) scare away the monsters, OR exchange places with Tartarus, and take over the Underworld. To help his friends, Percy would transform into his worst nightmare. *Mentions of Gotham, Batman and co. in one of the chapters. **I own none of the characters. All references and characters go to their respective owners.