"If I hadn't been so blinded by those two, maybe I would have noticed it sooner. Maybe I wouldn't have been playing tag with two boys who weren't interested in me or cared about me as much as you." Cassidy is a compassionate high school girl. But, like a lot of teen girls, Cassidy is boy crazy. She dreams of what it would be like to pick between two suitors and have them fight over her. Who are these suitors? They are none other than Logan, the athlete and class president, and Zander, the boy who loves to read but still cuts class. With the help of her best friend Julian, she tries to pick between the qualities of them both to see who she would rather be with. But, she has more than those two who will try to win her over.