They were just friends. That was it. Right? Athena and Haley were just friends. They grew up together, Haley being the hot popular friend, Athena being the hot not-so-popular friend. They were every movie cliche duo. When Haley first started dating Dylan, Athena hated it but she wrote it off as just feeling worried for her friend but she knew, deep down, she was jealous. Not of Haley but of Dylan. Maybe Dylan was a distraction for Haley so she didn't have to face the truth. She was hopelessly in love with Athena Gray. [Modern Family] [Season 1-11] [Haley Dunphy x Fem!OC] [only has a mature rating for strong language ya know the usual]
36 parts