My Neighbors Are Monster Girls (Male Reader X Fem Monsters) REQUEST: OPEN

The Tables Have Turned (Lemon)

Y/N's POV:

Tonight was the night, the night where Aiya would be coming after me during the night, and have her way with me. But, this time I was prepared for her thanks to the tips that Albina gave me, I had a lighter and a small bottle of caffeine pills, now there was just the time to wait for Aiya to show up. I turned off all of the lights in my living room, bedroom, kitchen and bathroom, only the moonlight shining through my window became my only source of light now

'I just have to follow the plan, and just hope for the best...' I locked every single door and window in my apartment, except my bedroom window which I left wide open, I sat down on my bed, completely nude, knowing how Aiya could turn out, she wouldn't miss the opportunity to try to DO IT with me in my bedroom with me naked

'Entrance open, bait set, everything is ready' I opened up the small bottle, and put three caffeine pills which taste exactly like coffee inside of my mouth, I placed my hands in my pockets, keeping my left hand on the lighter that Albina gave to me 'Now, I'm ready' I waited on the edge of my bed, facing the open window with anticipation, then as if on cue, I noticed a long, slender pointy leg coming to the window sill, then another leg, and another

Until, I saw a pair of human-like hands came next, followed by Aiya's face that had a wide smile on it "Hello again~" She greeted, then in a quick blink of an eye, Aiya was now already an inch away from my face 'Holy crap!' Aiya suddenly pinned me down by my shoulders, laying me on my back "I was expecting for you to try and plan how to escape me on this night, but it would seem that you didn't, could it be that you actually enjoyed our last meet up?" She asked

'Ok, just follow with the plan, Y/N' I opened my mouth to stick out my tongue in response to Aiya's question, she soon gave me a wide, creepy smile "Oh?, does the worm want a kiss from his mistress?...fine, I will grant your wish, maggot" Aiya said 'Wait, so am I a worm or a maggot?' Aiya suddenly pressed her lips against mine, with our mouths open our tongues immediately touched, Aiya's kissing was a bit aggressive, but it wasn't anything that I could handle

Since I had the caffeine pills underneath my tongue, I knew that the caffeine was mixing with my own saliva which was undoubtedly getting in to Aiya's mouth, her eyes suddenly went wide as she was startled by something, and I think that I knew what it was. However, just as she was getting ready to back away, I quickly brought my hands to her face, and used my tongue to force the caffeine down Aiya's throat

Aiya grabbed the both of my wrists with her hands, and pinned my arms down to the bed "What was that!?, what did you just-" Just before Aiya could finish her sentence, I noticed her body pulsate for a quick second, then Aiya's face instantly became red with blush, and her upper body fell on top of me

"What did you just doooo?..." Aiya asked in a drunken voice, I used this moment lift her off of me, and placed her on her back with me kneeling over her midsection, staying away from her spider half that was clearly limp as well 'Again, this feels so wrong'

"I just used a little caffeine" I replied "C-Caffiene?" Aiya asked "Yeah, it's apparently your weakness" I replied, I placed my hand on the side of her face, but as my thumb touched my lips, Aiya opened her mouth, in curiosity, I used my thumb to rub the inside of her cheek, this caused Aiya to give a low moan as I did this, I remembered what Albina said about Aiya becoming sadistic at night, but was she also in to submission and dominance as well?

"Are you being submissive to me just because you can't move this time?" I asked, I used my fingers to gently bring Aiya's tongue out, I drew my hand back, but Aiya kept her tongue out, her face carried a look of arousal with her eyes fixed on mine "This is punishment for our last meeting" I said, I brought the top of her clothing from her shoulders down to her midsection, exposing her bare breasts "W-What do you plan on doing?" Aiya asked "Isn't it obvious?, it's my turn to have some fun with you" I replied