Nickcarraway Stories

63 Stories

Wallflower by HillaryStreisand
#1
Wallflowerby HillaryStreisand
What if it wasn't Gatsby and Daisy that met before the war, but Nick and Jordan? Jordan is a young girl of 18 that is caught in the middle of her older and younger siste...
Natsby by Prussiangal
#2
Natsbyby Ira Kirkland
Nick Carroway has never been alone. Lost, perhaps. But never alone. That is, until a mysterious call sends Gatsby away and leaves Nick in charge of the mansion until he...
He's Out of my Ivy League by TBnBexx
#3
He's Out of my Ivy Leagueby TB & Bexx
Nick Carraway could never imagine how much a simple move would change his life. He could never, not in a million years, predict the earth-shattering smile of Jay Gatsby...
Nick/Gatsby. The great Gatsby. (BoyXBoy) AE by lunaticfringe101
#4
Nick/Gatsby. The great Gatsby. (Bo...by Just living life 🌈
So this is like an Alternative Ending (AE). (Not finished but will continue to upload new chapters as I finish them.) (I don't mind if you point grammar, spelling, or...
Nicole Carraway | The Great Gatsby by Crimsonsky132
#5
Nicole Carraway | The Great Gatsbyby Crimson
One minor change can bear life and death to many, and perhaps Jay Gatsby outruns his treacherous fate. There are plenty of flowers in the garden, after all. Great Gatsb...
Let Me Occupy Your Mind [Natsby Fanfiction] by iwritefromtimetotime
#6
Let Me Occupy Your Mind [Natsby Fa...by iwritefromtimetotime
A Great Gatsby fanfiction (Jay x Nick).🌷 ᴜɴғɪɴɪsʜᴇᴅ ••• Jay "West Egg Millionaire" Gatsby planned every single detail of his life, for the sole purpose of one...
The Great Gatsby: The High School AU by srm62405
#7
The Great Gatsby: The High School...by srm62405
High school senior, Nick Carraway, moves to New York and attends the same school as his cousin, Daisy. Nick meets many odd characters in his new school, by far the mos...
Gay Implications of Nick Carraway in The Great Gatsby by MHeying
#8
Gay Implications of Nick Carraway...by Monty Heying
This essay concludes that Nick Carraway, first-person narrator of The Great Gatsby, is cast by Fitzgerald as a closeted homosexual and proposes reasons why Scott Fitzger...
Ashes In My Mouth by Fanficwriter12511
#9
Ashes In My Mouthby Fanficwriter12511
A short Natsby Fanfic <3
Completed
Forebidden Love  by JayXNickforever
#10
Forebidden Love by Laura
Two Gays in the 1920s, navigating their feeling for each other.
"MY GREAT GATSBY" by JakobOakly
#11
"MY GREAT GATSBY"by 1nc0nsp1cu0us
A thoughtfully written parody of The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, except it is written completely different and with an entirely different outcome that changes t...
The Great Gatsby but Homosexual and in Highschool by bi_ohazard
#12
The Great Gatsby but Homosexual an...by Apollo
Want to read the swaggest gay fanfic? Well look no further buckaroo! Welcome to Natsby, the high school dream. Chemistry projects usually lead to sex, usually. Nick i...
Blood Diamonds (Natsby) by whatthehonkkkkkkkk
#13
Blood Diamonds (Natsby)by anna
After Nick Carraway helps Jay Gatsby get away with the murder of George Wilson, they keep up their facades while undercover as hitmen in the East Egg. As their connectio...
The great Gatsby {Jay Gatsby x Nick Carraway} by cR0w_B0ys
#14
The great Gatsby {Jay Gatsby x Nic...by Kieran/Remus/Milo
I wrote this as My English class final. This is just for funzies!! You should totally post about this. It'd be funny. Also the characters do not belong to me. They belon...
unloved [nick x gatsby]  by bee-autifulhuman
#15
unloved [nick x gatsby] by mayor of your city
they can never be together... gatsby loves daisy more than anything. nick loves gatsby more than anything. how far will nick go to get gatsby's love?
HIS FINAL GOODBYE - The Great Gatsby *Ending rewrite by VibeswithAya84
#16
HIS FINAL GOODBYE - The Great Gats...by VibeswithAya84
In this version, Gatsby is not dead but is not alive in the version he wanted to be in. Daisy is now near him but is still the furthest away from Gatsbys' mind. Some wou...
Completed
The Great Gatsby  by DarkScidiousQueen
#17
The Great Gatsby by DarkScidiousQueen
Set in the Jazz Age on Long Island, near New York City, the novel depicts first-person narrator Nick Carraway's interactions with mysterious millionaire Jay Gatsby and G...
Summertime Sadness  by CosetteCarraway
#18
Summertime Sadness by Cosette Carraway
It's the 1920s, and Anna Ruby, who frequents Gatsby's parties, immediately becomes infatuated with Nick Carraway. But Nick is enamored with Gatsby, and will never stop r...
The woman he needed by GoddessLadyArtemis
#19
The woman he neededby GoddessLadyArtemis
George Wilson is tired of his wife's cheating so he decided to move away but his plans change when he meets a lovely woman, named (y/n), who happens to be rich. Will she...