STRANGER:RUKE/JUKE (REQUEST)

363 6 23
                                    

Description: Reggie sings Stranger (by Jeremy Shada) while wathing Julie and Luke spend time together.

Warning:Sad Reggie

Requested by Jayloslife Thank you for your request! I hope you like it!

Note: This is after they played the Orpheum an Julie can touch the boys. Also, the italics are Reggie singing/humming the song.

REGGIE'S POV

I stand here, thinking about the time, before we died, when Luke would look at me like that. Back when we were dating and he woud smile at me, like nothing could ever make him sad. But he had never smiled at me the way he smiles at Julie. I guess what hurts the most is how quickly he replaced me with Julie. I close my eyes, forcing back tears as I start humming a song I have been working on.

Little did I know
You were gone before you even left
Little did I know
Our kiss goodbye was the last I'd ever get
Little did I know
You'd already tasted someone else's lips
Little did I know
You'd move on so quick

I look up to see whisper something into Julie's ear, making her smile. She leans uo and kisses his lips softly and I quickly look away again, wiping my tears with my sleeve. It hurts, how quickly I was replaced, considering we never actually broke up. But I guess our relationship meant nothing to him. I remember walking along the beach with him and all the little picnics we planned. I hold onto those memories, hoping for something that would help me see how real we were to him.

Now I'm searching through our memories
Searching for ways to you and me
But no matter what I do
There's a stranger holding you
Ooh-oh-ooh
A stranger's holding you

He picks her up and puts himon her shoulders, laughing and running down the street. He never did that with me. I look away, more tears welling up. I never believed in broken hearts, but now I know what they mean. This pain I feel hurts so bad,

Little did I know
The memory of us would haunt these streets
Little did I know
I'd have so much to say but no words to speak
Little did I know
I'd see you with him at the place we used to meet
Little did I know
You have a smile that I'd never seen

He smiles that smile again. Maybe it's true. Maybe I could never make him happy. Maybe we only happened because he was bored. I keep trying to think lf a time he looked that happy with me.

And I'm searching through our memories
Searching for ways to you and me
But no matter what I do
There's a stranger holding you
Ooh-oh-ooh
A stranger's holding you
Little did I know
You only told me what I wanted to hear
Little did I know
You lied every time you said, "I love you, dear"

None of it was real. He was never this happy when he was with me. I could never make him happy. I mean, how could I? Every memory; there was never a time he smiled or laughed like that. He's never looked at me that way. I watch him put Julie back on the ground and spin her around. I make eye contact with him before quickly looking away.

Now I've searched through all our memories
There's no way to you and me
No matter what I do
A stranger's gonna be holding you
Now I'm seeing all the signs I'd missed
The person I loved didn't really exist
After all that we've been through
I guess, you're just a stranger too
Ooh-oh-ooh
You're just a stranger too
Ooh-oh-ooh

He stops twirling Julie and starts walking towards me.

" Hey Reggie, what's wrong?" He asks. I look him in the eyes sadly.

"The stranger was always you."  I sing softly before turning away, walking briskly down the street we had walked down many times before, desperately trying to get away from him.






Hey guys! How are you all today? I hope you are all doing well! I have some great news! My crush and I told each other our feelings and things are heading in a great direction! I am so happy! I honestly couldn't have done it without thatscorpiobish, so thank you a million! I honestly cannot believe it happened! It's like, a dream come true! I'll try to keep you guys updated on our relationship! What did you guys think of that chapter? Kind of sad, wasn't it? That song is amazing though! Let me know what you thought of it in the comments! Don't forget to comment and vote! As always, feel free to leave any requests in the comments or in my dm. Thank you for your support! I love you all! Stay safe! See you in the next chapter!
-Emily♥

Julie And The Phantoms OneshotsWhere stories live. Discover now