Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When You Meet Masky

I stopped by a nearby cheesecake shop on my home, I was (dream job), and was luckily very successful. I was suppose to be meeting my boyfriend/girlfriend here, he/she said they had a surprise to for me. We had been dating since we were sixteen, I was now twenty four, eight years of relationship. My friend (friends name) teased me saying maybe they will purpose. I saw them walk in and waved at me, he/she was so beautiful/handsome. With their (insert dream boy/girl), it was just astounding. "Hey, babe", they said, giving me a hug, I felt a twinch as they didn't kiss me. "You said you had a surprise?" I said. They sat, laughing nervously. "Oh, yeah.. you see, I cheated on you.. and.. now this other person and I are starting a family." They said, my world felt shattered. "I'm sorry, just, they were-" "were what? Better than me? Nicer?" I interupted harshly. "No, it's just, ugh. Jeez, you're a brat, I thought you would understand, but no, you don't", they remarked harshly, standing up. "I understand! You cheated in me, and you're starting a family with this person! What fid you expect me to do? Congratulate you for cheating? Oh, good for you, you became my dream boy/girl to a complete dick within two seconds, bravo!" I exclaimed, catching the attention of the workers and a few customers.

"Ugh! Just be happy for me! I'm happy!" (Insert name) yelled, pushing me, I fell to the floor, the breath getting knocked out of me. A worker grabbed him/her and showed them out, someone ran to my side. "Hey, hey, are you okay?" Someone asked, he was... wearing a white mask with slightly femine features on it. "I'm Masky", he said, he had black hair, and was wearing a orange jacket. "(Y-your name)" I said, this was Masky! He was a proxy of Slenderman.... he nodded his head. "Here, let me buy you some cheesecake", he said, helping me up. Everyone was muttering about the incident. My face grew pale with embarrassment, I felt faint. "Hey, hey, are you okay?" Masky asked, wrapping an arm around my waist, I fumbled. Masky helped me sit down, he sat across from me. "May we have some water?" He called, I buried my face in my hands and sobbed. "Oh, no no, it's okay, (your name)", Masky said, he pulled my hands down from my face, putting them on the table and covering them with his own gloved hands.

The waiter gave us a glass of water. "Here, let's get you some cheesecake. Okay? What's your favorite? I'll pay for it.." Masky said, I shook my head. "Oh, I can't have you do that for me Masky.." I said, "it's fine", he said. "Are yous sure?" "Yes, I'm sure" I hesitated telling him my favorite cheesecake, which was (favorite cheesecake). "Oh really? Mine too! Guess that's a win win, right?" He said, I smiled some, rubbing at my eyes. He went up and ordered the cheesecake, coming back with a tray of it. "So.. how's things working with... Slenderman?" I questioned, he froze, but chuckled lightly. "I guess you know about that then, hm? Heh, well, I guess everything is fine.. Hoodie is with him now at the mansion, along with the other pastas." He said, I smiled. "That's really amazing, just.. wow.. I honestly didn't believe you guys were... real. Sorry if that was offensive.." I said quickly, worried. "Oh its fine, most people don't and if anyone asks", he started, turning his words to a whisper," I just tell them I'm cosplaying."

I smiled, laughing slightly and rubbing my eyes. We both began to eat cheesecake and began chatting about our jobs, laughing about stories. "Okay, but, one time, BEN was on his way home one night and he went to go through the TV, but Jeff was watching it and was half asleep and threw the remote at his face. He wouldn't talk to Jeff for the rest of the night", Masky kind of laughed, I surprisingly giggled at that, blushing slightly. "Well, this place is going to close soon.." I said, he nodded. "It was nice meeting you, maybe we could do this again?" He questioned, I nodded my head and smiled. "I would like that", I said, we exchanged numbers and he walked me out, holding the door for me. "I'll see you some other time!" He called as he began walking down the street, I waved, smiling to myself.