~Your first kill with~
Aries: Eyeless Jack
Taurus: The Rake
Gemini: Glitchy Red
Cancer: Lost Silver
Leo: Laughing Jack
Virgo: Smile Dog
Libra: Ticci Toby
Scorpio: Masky
Sagittarius: BEN Drowned
Capricorn: Slenderman
Aquarius: Jeff The Killer
Pisces: Hoodie