My Little Pony - The Legend of Friendship (MLP remake with male OC added)

117. The Other Half - Part 3

Twilight's castle...

Two fierce battles were unfolding inside the castle of Equestria's newest princess. In the throne room, the princess of Friendship herself was working together with Summershine to fight off Arcana, an intruder who wants to take the Elements of Harmony that reside inside both Star Twinkle and Summershine. And only a few rooms away, a battle between Star Twinkle and the pony in the black armor was taking place, who revealed himself as the real Star Twinkle while the Star Twinkle that lived in Ponyville was just a clone. One was a battle of strength and the other a battle of emotion and will.

The latter one was about to end with one last charge from both Star Twinkles. Both of them were in their Unicorn form and ran towards each other with magic emitting from their horns. Once they clashed, a light started to fill the whole room with both of the Star Twinkles in the center of it.

...

Memories started flowing into Star Twinkle. He found himself in the middle of what looked like an endless place where everywhere he looked at, all he could see was just the color white. "Where am I?" He asked, hoping that someone would miraculously answer.

"Your memories," someone actually replied. It was the Star Twinkle in the black armor who seemed to have appeared out of nowhere.

Star Twinkle looked over to the pony. "My memories?" He asked confused. "But...there is nothing!" He pointed out.

"Exactly..." the pony in the black armor replied. "A perfect replication of your memories. Just like how you are a replication of me."

Hearing those words no longer made Star Twinkle angry or frustrated. He looked over to the pony in the black armor. He looked exactly like him, down to the last hair. It was as if he was looking at a mirror. He saw the serious expression that he looked at so many times in his past while looking at his own reflection.

Star Twinkle let out a defeated sigh. "I really am just a clone, am I?" He asked.

The pony in the black armor started to show a little sympathy for Star Twinkle. "Does that make you sad?" He asked. "Does it make you sad knowing that your whole existence was just to be a substitute or that you were meant to return to me anyway? Are you frustrated that the time you spent with your friends in Ponyville was less important because you were a clone?"

After hearing those words, Star Twinkle lowered his eyebrows. "Huh..." he said, much to the pony in the black armor's confusion.

"Huh?" He quoted confused.

"Now that you said all those things..." Star Twinkle said as he began to come to a realization. "I don't think I am sad about any of those things...which is weird because those are the exact things I was worried about. But as soon as you said it I came to realize that there is no reason to be afraid."

The pony in the black armor was confused to hear that. "So you accept to become one again? I told you before that I will be in control since I am the original, and I intend to go on with my plan to take the Elements of Harmony from Summershine to get my friends back."

But Star Twinkle was not too sure about that. "And I think you will not do something like that." He said confidentially.

"What makes you so sure about that?" The pony in the black armor replied curiously.

Star Twinkle explained. "We are gonna become one again, that means that our memories will become one as well. Even though this place is completely white I do have memories of my own too. They might not be the same as yours but they are still there," Star Twinkle assured.

"So I get your memories and then what?" The pony in the black armor asked. "I have my mind set and your memories will not make a difference. It's my memories that are important after all."