Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When You Become Best Friends [Rewritten]

Slenderman:

You and Slender had been hanging around one another for about a month now which was enough time for a friendship to bloom among the two of you. It had become usual for the both of you to meet up in the woods and on rare occasions, your backyard. Today was no different as you found yourself wandering down the same dirt path through the woods that you've been taking for this entire month. "Hello, [Your Name], how are you today?" Slender suddenly asked from behind you, causing you to jump in surprise as you spun around on your heel to face him.

"I'm fine as always, what about you? How are you doing?" you asked, calming down as you both started to walk down the path together. Though, you found yourself having to pick up speed every now and then to keep in sync with the tall man who had an advantage in getting ahead of you due to those long legs of his.

"I'm doing well, child" he answered as your eyes narrowed.

"I thought I told you not to call me that, Slendy" your lips tugged up into a smirk as you listened to the sharp intake of air the faceless man beside you took, knowing that you had just pressed one of his many buttons by using that wretched nickname that he hated so much.

"And I thought I told you to never call me by that name ever again" Slender grumbled before chuckling as he watched you childishly stick your tongue out at him. The rest of the day had been spent with you two walking as you spoke with one another.

Jeff the Killer:

At first, you and Jeff didn't get along all that well at the start. From insulting one another to hateful glares, you wondered why he even kept coming back around. But, slowly the more you two spoke with one another the more you learned that you had quite a bit in common and by the end of the month you were best buds. The insults you threw at each other now were only half-hearted as you both were currently seated in your living room. You had your legs stretched out on the couch and resting on top of his lap while holding a bowl of popcorn.

Unlike Jeff, you were engrossed in the show you and him were watching on Netflix. Even if you weren't looking at him, you still were able to smack his hand away when it started to slowly inch closer towards your bowl of popcorn. "Ow! Come on, share, dammit!" Jeff snapped as you shook your head, never once removing your eyes off from the television screen.

"If you want some then go make your own, there's plenty of bags in the kitchen" you muttered, bringing another piece of popcorn up to your mouth.

"But, the kitchen is so far away!" Jeff groaned, dramatically throwing his head back.

"Ugh! Fine, I guess you can have some" you rolled your eyes and held the bowl out to the raven-haired man. "Not that much!" you snapped when grabbed a whole handful and stuffed it all in his mouth. With a shake of your head, you chuckled as you watched him happily munch on the popcorn and turn his attention back to the show, with you soon doing the same.

Laughing Jack:

"[Your Name], have you seen Jack anywhere? I can't seem to find him" [Sister's Name] whined as she came barging into your room and causing you to look up from your book.

"No, not really" you shook your head as you quickly adverted your gaze back down towards your book.

"You really sure you haven't seen him?" she asked, eyes narrowed as she crept closer towards you with a look of suspicion on her face. "I've noticed that you two have been hanging around each other a lot recently, you're not trying to steal him away from me, are you?"

"Yes, I'm sure and no, I'm not trying to steal him away from you. Now leave" you rolled your eyes as you waved the little girl away, watching from the corner of your eye as she pouted before finally turning away and leaving your room. She wasn't exactly wrong to think that you had been trying to steal the clown away from her, seeing how you and L.J had been hanging around one another this entire month, slowly developing a friendship. The second your bedroom door clicked shut, a cloud of black and white smoke appeared, and your monochrome friend came popping out before you. "You know, [Sister's Name] is looking for you" you hummed as you placed your bookmark inside the book before closing it.