Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When He Scares You

Slenderman:
There was no doubt that you had a fear of heights, it was one of the reason you rarely let Slender pick you up seeing as how high off the ground you would be. Sitting in his office at the manor, he started to think it would be slight fun to use this fear of yours to scare you. He loves you dearly but he thought it would be a fun little idea, nothing that would cause any harm. You were sitting outside the Creepypasta manor, you sat on the porch steps watching as Ben, Sally, and Jeff played with Smile as they all soon ran to the back of the manor, leaving you alone. As you sat there fiddling with your fingers you didn't notice your boyfriend teleport behind you.

Suddenly something wrapped around your ankle and pulled you up into the air. You screamed, fear coursing through you as you looked down at the ground. Looking at the thing that had picked you up with wide frightful eyes, you soon narrowed them when you saw Slender's faceless face. "Put me down" you said, crossing your arms as you glared at him. Doing as he was told he quickly sat you down and bowed his head as you turned away from him.

"I'm sorry [Your Name], I love you" Slender mumbled as he wrapped his long arms around you. Biting your lip you tried to stay mad at him but couldn't help but turn and hug him.

"It's alright, just don't do it again or I swear to God I will break those long legs of yours" you threatening jokingly, causing him to laugh a little.

Jeff the Killer:
Jeff loved trying to scare you, but it never really worked in his favor at times. You either didn't noticed and when you did you didn't seem to react. Finally you were able to fall asleep and get the well needed rest you longed for without having to use your sleeping pills. While you were fast asleep on the couch, Jeff entered your home, like usual your parents where away, they never really did like staying home that much. Walking into the living room he spotted your sleeping form and his everlasting smile widens even more.

Slowly he walked over to you before leaning real close to your sleeping face and taking in a deep breath he released a loud scream, causing you to jolt awake and throw your fist up towards Jeff, landing a perfect hit on his almost invisible nose. Jeff stumbled backwards, crying out in pain as he held his face. "Oh God, Jeff I'm sorry I didn't know it was you!" you exclaimed as you sat up and tried to comfort him.

"Shit, [Your Name] that hurts! I expected you to get scared not punch me!" Jeff grunted in pain.

"I'm sorry, it's just a natural reflex; I love you so much I didn't mean it" you said hugging him tightly while burying your face into his chest. Jeff sighed and wrapped his arms around you, before blushing as you leaned up and kissed his nose which was beginning to bruise.

Laughing Jack:
Laughing Jack always found it amusing that you had a fear of spiders. Every time there was one in the room, big or small, you would run out of the room and beg him to kill it. Which he never did of course, he usually scoop them up and throw them outside. Today he wanted to scare you, just terrify you and what better way to do that then give you a pet spider as a present. Wrapping the box up in black and white wrapping paper and poking a few holes into it he carried the box which held a full grown tarantula in it.

He walked into your room to find you reading, something you usually do when bored, yet you never showed much interest in the books you read. You looked up at him with a raised eyebrow as you looked at the box in his hands with suspicion. "What's in the box?" you asked as you watched your boyfriend shake with suppressed laughter.

"Just a little gift for you" Jack said, holding the box out for you as you took it from him. Sitting it on your bed, you pulled the wrapping paper off and opened the box before screaming as you saw the tarantula crawling around the bottom of the box. It's legs raising and lowering as it walked. Jumping up you ran out of your room and into the hallway.