Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When He Kisses You [Rewritten]

Slenderman:

Despite the fact that you and Slender had been dating for a while, the two of you had yet to share your first kiss. The more you thought about it, the more you couldn't help but wonder if the faceless man even had the ability to kiss—you know, since he doesn't have a face and all. "Slender" you called out from your spot on your couch, parents currently away shopping and leaving you to watch over the house, so of course, you took this opportunity to invite the tall man over.

"Yes?" he called back from the kitchen, you had no idea what he was doing or what he was even looking for in there. But, you had an inkling that it was something that wasn't junk food.

"Can you...can you even kiss?" you shyly asked, hesitant at first to let the question slip past your lips. "You know? Since you don't have a face and all" you quickly added, twiddling your fingers as you watched Slender poke his head through the kitchen doorway to stare at you with that blank canvas he called a face. You watched how creases formed and gave the illusion that he was raising an eyebrow that simply wasn't there.

"Why do you ask?" he asked, now fully entering the living room and causing you to tilt your head all the way back to keep looking at his face. You never realized that he was tall enough to almost reach the ceiling of your living room.

"N-no reason" you sputtered out, not really wanting to explain your reasoning as you forced yourself to pay attention to the Tv and whatever random show that was currently playing. A blush soon dusting over your cheeks and darkened as Slender stepped in front of the screen, his head tilted downwards as he watched you nervously start to sweat.

"Close your eyes" he suddenly ordered.

"What?" you owlishly blinked, taken aback by the faceless man's demands.

"I said, close your eyes" he calmly repeated, bending down to your eye level. Slowly nodding your head, you did as you were told and slipped your eyes shut—trusting your boyfriend. Your eyebrows furrowed when the sudden sound of fabric ripping filled the air before something soft touched against your lips. You were confused at first, sitting perfectly still before coming to the realization that Slender was kissing you. Smiling, you wrapped your arms around his neck and quickly returned the kiss.

Soon pulling away for a breath of air, you slowly blinked your eyes open as a wide smile spread across your lips. Eyeing the man's faceless face in confusion when you noticed that it looked like it always had—making you wonder how he had pulled off such a trick. But, slowly you shook your head and decided that that was a question that could be answered another day. "That was amazing" you breathed out, giggling as Slender chuckled.

"Indeed."

Jeff the Killer:

In the time that you and Jeff had been dating, the smiling killer had yet to kiss you and you couldn't help but be infuriated by that fact. You didn't have the guts to ask him for a kiss and it didn't look like he was going to do it anytime soon...but, you couldn't help but wonder what it would feel like to kiss those scarred lips of his. Would it feel weird? Rough? Uncomfortable?

Those were the questions that would normally plague your mind whenever the two of you would hang out and today was no different as you were currently seated on the couch with him at Slender's manor. Both of you found yourself alone as everyone else seemingly had to go out and do one thing or another and even though they didn't specify what they planned on doing, you had a clever idea on what it was. "Hey, [Your Name]?" Jeff's voice suddenly brought you out of your thoughts.