Aries: Tails Doll, Sully (Homicidal Liu)
Taurus: BEN Drowned, Offenderman, Smile Dog
Gemini: Grinny Cat, Jane the Killer
Cancer: BEN Drowned, Jeff the Killer, Homicidal Liu
Leo: Zalgo, Lazari, Tails Doll
Virgo: The Puppeteer, Laughing Jack
Libra: Lyra (Toby's sister), Masky
Scorpio: Ticci Toby, Bloody Painter, Smile Dog
Sagittarius: Nurse Ann, Nina the Killer, The Rake
Capricorn: Sally, Kate the Chaser
Aquarius: Lost Silver, Nina the Killer, Homicidal Liu
Pisces: BEN Drowned, Jeff the Killer, Jane the Killer
