Aries: Jeff the Killer
Taurus: Jane the Killer
Gemini: Zero
Cancer: BEN Drowned
Leo: Sally
Virgo: Clockwork
Libra: Laughing Jack
Scorpio: Ticci Toby
Sagittarius: Masky
Capricorn: Homicidal Liu (he came back from the dead and now he pranks you)
Aquarius: Nina the Killer
Pisces: Eyeless Jack