Aries: Jeff the Killer
Taurus: Laughing Jack
Gemini: Ticci Toby
Cancer: BEN Drowned
Leo: Suicide Sadie
Virgo: Homicidal Liu
Libra: Jane the Killer
Scorpio: Sally
Sagittarius: Three random people you met in the woods.
Capricorn: Kate The Chaser
Aquarius: Eyeless Jack
Pisces: it literally just appears in front of you.