Your gender doesn't matter here, just choose whichever you're more attracted to.
Girls:
Aries: Suicide Sadie
Taurus: Zero
Gemini: Vailly Evans
Cancer: Jane the Killer
Leo: Nina the Killer and The Scarecrow Girl (at the same time)
Virgo: Laughing Jill
Libra: Judge Angels
Scorpio: Nurse Ann
Sagittarius: Rouge
Capricorn: Ally The Slender Doll
Aquarius: Kate The Chaser and Nurse Ann (different nights)
Pisces: Clockwork
Boys:
Aries: Homicidal Liu
Taurus: Eyeless Jack
Gemini: Laughing Jack
Cancer: Jeff the Killer
Leo: The Doll Maker
Virgo: BEN Drowned and Masky (different nights)
Libra: Hoodie
Scorpio: Hobo Heart
Sagittarius: Jason The Toymaker and Bloody Painter (at the same time)
Capricorn: Kagekao
Aquarius: Ticci Toby
Pisces: Lost Silver
