Aries: Eyeless Jack
Taurus: Slenderman
Gemini: Jane the Killer
Cancer: Slenderman
Leo: Tails Doll
Virgo: The Chess Master
Libra: Sally
Scorpio: Lost Silver
Sagittarius: Homicidal Liu
Capricorn: BEN Drowned
Aquarius: Nurse Ann
Pisces: Offenderman
Who apologizes for hurting you
Aries: Eyeless Jack
Taurus: Slenderman
Gemini: Jane the Killer
Cancer: Slenderman
Leo: Tails Doll
Virgo: The Chess Master
Libra: Sally
Scorpio: Lost Silver
Sagittarius: Homicidal Liu
Capricorn: BEN Drowned
Aquarius: Nurse Ann
Pisces: Offenderman