Supernatural Imagines

Sam x Reader//Over The Moon

Song of choice: Break The Distance- Ashton Edminster

Imagine: whilst playing a game of truth or dare, you and Sam admit you have feelings for each other.

Requested by moosechester83

"Okay, you're up (friend). Truth or dare?" Someone from the circle called out, staring down your friend. It had been going on like this for quite a while; the alcohol in all of your systems telling you "oh, this is fun!" Well, it's not fun when your friend decides that it's your turn to embarrass yourself in front of your friends and people you don't know. After cracking a few raw eggs on someone's head, your friend turned towards you with an evil glint in their eyes.

"Truth or dare, y/n?" You gulped, already knowing where this was going. No matter what you chose, the question would be mortifying. Clearing your throat, you answer quietly.

"Truth." Truth can't be too bad, right? Your friend laughed maniacally; or at least it sounded like it to your ears. They kept their mouth closed for a few seconds, wanting you to freak out. Finally they spoke, and you fell cold.

"Do you like someone-like do you like like them?" They questioned, taking a swig of beer. You took a deep, shaky breath, trying to stall time to think of a loophole out of this. The person you liked- no, loved- was sitting a few feet away from you, awaiting your answer as everyone else was except more intently.

"Um, yeah I guess..." You muttered, gaining a giggle from your friend.

"Who?" You shook your head. There was no way you were going to answer that question.

"That's two questions (friend). Okay, um... Sam, truth or dare?" You stated, quickly changing the topic as your friend pouted and crossed their arms. Sam's eyes widened in surprise at being put in the spotlight. He cleared his throat and shakily replied.

"T-truth." Sam's eyes shifted back and forward nervously, no doubt fearing what you would tell him to reveal. He was lucky though; you weren't as bad as everyone else in the room. You smiled slightly and ran a hand through your hair.

"Uh, what's your favourite animal?" You questioned lamely, gaining boo's from everyone in the room. You looked down at your lap and sighed softly.

"A dog." He replied. You glanced up at him to see that he was smiling at you, though there was a sad twinkle in his beautiful brown eyes. You tilted your head slightly, confused at why he was sad. Suddenly your friend leaned next to you and whispered quite loudly.

"You like the amazing Sam Winchester, don't you?" Their breath reeked of alcohol which made you roll your eyes and laugh awkwardly.

"Can we talk about this later?" You forced out. They laughed loudly in your ear causing you to wince.

"Sammy she likes you!" Everybody laughed and you heard someone whistle. You winced and shuddered, a flush coming into your cheeks. Sam stared at you intently.

"Truth or dare y/n?" He said. Everybody suddenly got quiet, awaiting your answer.

"Uh..." You stuttered out, looking around the room. "Truth?" With a glance back to him, you knew what was coming.

"Who do you have a crush on?" You smiled nervously and bit your lip, looking anywhere but him. Did you have to answer this in front of everyone? Well, they probably wouldn't remember considering they are all very drunk. You forced out a laugh and looked down at the carpeted floor.

"W-well, it's kind of you." You muttered, staring up at him with red cheeks and anxious eyes. Sam opened his mouth to speak but he was interrupted by a knock on the door and a loud, angry voice telling them all to wrap this up and go to bed or else they wouldn't let you all sleep for weeks. With horror on all of your youthful faces, you ran out of the room.

"Hey y/n wait up!" Someone called from behind you. You cursed under your breath and turned around to look at Sam. He stopped in front of you and put his hands on your shoulders. "You really like me? It's not the alcohol talking, right?" He queried nervously. You nodded shyly and he laughed slightly with a look of relief on his face.

"I hope that's okay?" Slipped out of your mouth. Sam laughed again, his eyes brighter than the sun during mid-day. He pulled you closer and placed his lips on yours. Your eyes fluttered closed and your arms wrapped around his neck. With a giggle you pulled away.

"I'm over the moon right now." You mumbled out excitedly. Sam laughed and pulled you in for another kiss before hugging you and laying his head on yours.

"I am too."

-
This is a bit short but it's very fluffy and I love writing fluffy Sam. It's my favourite thing to write. I'm sorry this is up so late! I've been busy and will be busy soon again with school so I'm determined to write as much as I possibly can this week before school starts.

Hope you like this!

stay thirsty my memes,
noelle