My Kind Of Hell! (Male!Reader x Fem!Creepypasta)

Beginning Of A Harem

A/N: Hey guys! I'm back again with this story! It's been a while with my Christmas special, but I'm back into it!

Yami: About time. People have been waiting since you left them with the steamy love making with Ann.

A/N: Right, well this isn't going to be a lemon, but it's going to be, as the title explains, kinky.

Yami: Of course, Jill would be a perv.

A/N: Right, well let's have the reader here get into the story. Enjoy!

Y/N's POV

It's been three days since me and Ann... slept together. We've already explained to the others that we were a thing, but left out the other night for obvious reasons. If Benny found out, I'd never hear the end of it. If Clockwork found out she'd probably lecture me and then kill me for 'taking Ann's innocence'. Finally, Jill would likely get... 'ideas'. Well, more than she already has, as she kept making assumptions as me, Jill, Ann and all the others talked about this.

Y/N: For the last time Jill, I'm not doing anything like that to Ann!

Jill: Are you sure? Because people in relationships tend to-

Y/N: I said... We're not doing anything like that.

I shifted my voice unintentionally in frustration, making me sound more demonic for a second. This seemed to make Jill shut up for now.

Slenda: What was that?

Y/N: Some new addition to my absurd line up of powers? I don't know... Wait, that's besides the point!

Clockwork: You'd better not take advantage of Ann.

Y/N: I thought we moved past that! I couldn't take advantage of her even if I wanted to! 

Clockwork: And why's that?

Y/N: Oddly enough, I'd like for my limbs to stay connected to my body!

Benny: I thought you wanted to die though?

Y/N: I can't die now! I haven't even used the pool or gym here yet!

Jane: That's why you want to stay alive?

Y/N: Aside from the obvious, yes.

Jane: I must be missing something. What's the obvious?

Y/N: Ann.

Ann blushed a deep red after my statement. Jill also changed her expression as an idea seemed to pop into her head.

Jill: Hey, if having girls keeps you wanting to be alive, maybe some of us can join you?

Y/N: Huh!?

Benny: Jill, do you mean having Ann share him with you?

Jill: Maybe not just me~

Ann: What do you mean share him!? He's not an object to be passed around!

Jill: No, but maybe you'd be willing to let his 'object' be passed around~?

A dark blush spread across my face as Jill finished her idea. The old me would have jumped at the idea of being the lead man of a harem, but now I had Ann. Getting with other women at the same time with Ann would feel wrong. I mean, I bet she would fell horrible if she saw me-

Ann: Alright... But only if Y/N agrees!

Y/N: Eh?

I looked at Ann in disbelief as she spoke those words. She was ok with it? How was I supposed to process this!? On one hand, I had a pass to do what my dark and buried perverted mind would want. On the other hand, what if this was one of those tests? Like the kind where your partner tests your loyalty?