BFDI/BFB/TPOT Oneshots! ❤ - Book One

I need to save him... Pie x Cake

Requested by Puffballisbestobject

Flicker AU

Humanized

Plot: Pie is unable to prevent the death of Cake, and ends up very upset about it, until the end of the game, where they hang out.

Cake's POV

I looked in the very room I entered, searching for the murderer. Whoever they are, they want to kill me, as I am a survivor!

It was so scary, walking around all alone. And I wouldn't follow anyone because they could be the murderer and kill me!

I hid myself in the corner of the room, pulling knees up to my chest, and I began crying, which I do when I get too scared...

What will happen to me?

Taco's POV

I was the Witch, and Book was the murderer, meaning we had to help each other out. We were discussing a plan in a secret room.

"So what should we do, Taco? I can try to kill Pie, but she can just self heal, and your magic won't work against her!" Book worried.

I smirked. "Then kill Cake. Pie will try to save him, but I can block her magic, and Cake will be dead!"

Book smiled, "Good thinking Taco!"

"Now let'a find that boy..."
Pie's POV

I searched through the halls, trying to find the witch. Since I am the medic, I can prevent death, just like my team wants me to...

Though, voices in my head are telling me that Cake is going to get killed. The voices don't lie to me. I need to save him...

Though I have to find him, first...

I heard Taco and Book laughing maniacally in another room, along with Cake's scream!

I ran into that very room, and saw Cake about to die because Book was killing him! I used my power as a medic to heal him.

Though, Taco managed to block my power, and Cake died.

"Taco! I can't believe you!" I yelled at her. "WHY DID YOU LET BOOK KILL CAKE?!"

"It'a my job, idiot!" She replied rudely. "Well, since you are the only one remaining, Book and I win the game!"

I growled, feeling extremely upset. If I didn't swear to prevent death, Taco AND Book would have been killed for sure!

As everyone respawned, I looked for Cake, but I didn't see him anywhere.

I sighed, until someone hugged me from behind and shouted, "Babe!"

I recognized this person as Cake. "Cake!" I tackled him in a big hug, before tearing up.

"Pie, what's wrong? You look depressed..." He worried.

"I...tried to save your life by healing you, but Taco blocked my ability, and killed you, and I feel so darn guilty about it!" I vented to my boyfriend.

As I was crying, I felt his arms wrap around me. "It's okay, babe. You tried, and I am happy you did..."

Cake rested his head on my shoulder, amd snuggled into me. I blushed, and snuggled back with the cute boy...